UK General Election July 4th 2024 - Trading ONLY thread
- firlandsfarm
- Posts: 3305
- Joined: Sat May 03, 2014 8:20 am
The ability for our electoral system to expose statistical anomalies is clear. It cannot be right that Reform/Greens and others will get more votes than LibDems but only a very small fraction of their seats. How is that democracy when the rules are stacked against the minority parties. The problem is the government in power will never change a system that guarantees them a 50/50 chance of being in power!Euler wrote: ↑Fri Jul 05, 2024 10:46 amTaken from Chris Fawcett on X
Looks like Labour in 2024 will end up with under 10,000,000 votes to get 411+ seats.
Labour under Corbyn in 2019 had a crushing defeat with 10,295,912 votes and only got 203 seats. In 2017 Labour got 262 seats and 12,877,918. Almost 3m more than Starmer's massive majority got.
- firlandsfarm
- Posts: 3305
- Joined: Sat May 03, 2014 8:20 am
I'm not sure you are right to say the King/Queen "has to take his advice", I think you will find he/she just does ... there would be uproar if he said "thanks but I was thinking of asking Jeremy Corbyn"!!Derek27 wrote: ↑Fri Jul 05, 2024 10:58 amApparently, the King, after accepting Sunak's resignation, is required to ask Sunak for advice on who he should call to form a government, where Sunak is constitutionally required to say Starmer and likewise, the King has to take his advice.
What a shit show our constitution is!!



Known as the "Mother of Parliaments", we actually have one of the greatest constitutions in the world - The Westminster model bas been copied over and over. A mix of Common Law, legislation and precedent. We do have some archaic customs though - such as asking the monarch for permission to form a government. It's entirely custom though. If anyone went against the protocol there would be uproarDerek27 wrote: ↑Fri Jul 05, 2024 10:58 amApparently, the King, after accepting Sunak's resignation, is required to ask Sunak for advice on who he should call to form a government, where Sunak is constitutionally required to say Starmer and likewise, the King has to take his advice.
What a shit show our constitution is!!
I studied and have qualifications in British Law, Govt and Politics and the British Constitution, and believe me there are far, far worse out there.
- jamesedwards
- Posts: 3941
- Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2018 6:16 pm
Lost on my long term "no overall majority" position thanks to Nigel. But had a fantastic night's trading with four-figure winnings across the turnout%, conservative seats >99.5, most seats without Labour, and Reform <7 seats markets. All just from my phone too. Next time I'm going to sit at my PC all night and do it properly.
That's what I don't like. We shouldn't rely on "uproar" in a democracy. On very rare occasions, flaws in the law become exposed resulting in public uproar and a change in the law, but this is something that happens every few years. I've no issue with traditions like the state opening of parliament, for something as important as selecting a PM, these daft traditions and protocols need to be binned.
And with that news, I'm lining you up as the starter on the next Election threadsniffer66 wrote: ↑Fri Jul 05, 2024 12:23 pmKnown as the "Mother of Parliaments", we actually have one of the greatest constitutions in the world - The Westminster model bas been copied over and over. A mix of Common Law, legislation and precedent. We do have some archaic customs though - such as asking the monarch for permission to form a government. It's entirely custom though. If anyone went against the protocol there would be uproar
I studied and have qualifications in British Law, Govt and Politics and the British Constitution, and believe me there are far, far worse out there.

Ha ! Did I forget to mention that was 40 years ago ?Euler wrote: ↑Fri Jul 05, 2024 12:43 pmAnd with that news, I'm lining you up as the starter on the next Election threadsniffer66 wrote: ↑Fri Jul 05, 2024 12:23 pmKnown as the "Mother of Parliaments", we actually have one of the greatest constitutions in the world - The Westminster model bas been copied over and over. A mix of Common Law, legislation and precedent. We do have some archaic customs though - such as asking the monarch for permission to form a government. It's entirely custom though. If anyone went against the protocol there would be uproar
I studied and have qualifications in British Law, Govt and Politics and the British Constitution, and believe me there are far, far worse out there.![]()

- jamesedwards
- Posts: 3941
- Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2018 6:16 pm
With Derek's somewhat freaky obsession with Sunak and the rain, I thought he would enjoy this image...
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.